Verse 1:

They hung their rules on every wall

Said holy men don't fall at all

But you fell anyway — right into me

And now we're both a heresy

Pre-chorus:

I wear your bite mark like a stain

You whisper my real name in the rain

That leaks through the chapel roof at night

God isn't here. But we're alright.

Chorus:

We only meet in the dark, my love

Where the candles don't judge and the stars are enough

They gave you a collar, they gave me a sin

But nobody told us what to do with this skin

That burns when you're close, that aches when you leave

This love is a thief — but I don't want to be free